Vaccine Effectiveness – Boosters (Adults)
Page last updated 19 October 2022
Key Points
Key Points are meant to be a scientific, factual summary of the available information that relates solely to the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 Vaccine, as supported by referenced publications within this section. Conclusions should not be drawn from the inclusion or absence of information.
- The emergence of SARS-CoV-2 variants of concern (VOC), such as Delta and Omicron highlighted waning immunity, which has been observed at > 3 months following 2 BNT162b2 vaccine doses.1-3
- CDC has made updated recommendations for COVID-19 vaccine booster doses in individuals 5 years of age and older.4-6
- Vaccine Effectiveness (VE) of a 3rd and 4th (booster) doses has been studied in Real World Evidence (RWE) studies.1, 2, 7-18
- RWE on VE against several outcomes of interest (such as confirmed infection, symptomatic infection, ED visits, severe disease, and hospitalization) has varied across studies, and these cannot be compared due to differences in study design and methodology. VE% (95% CI) ranges for BNT162b2, at listed times post last vaccine dose, are summarized below for periods of Delta (B.1.617.2) and Omicron (B.1.1.529) variant predominance:
Outcome | VE % (95% CI) of 3rd (1st booster) dose 1, 7, 8, 15-17 [Reference: Unvacccinated] Age ≥ 16 years |
VE % (95% CI) of 3rd (1st booster) dose 2, 9-14, 17 [Reference: 2 doses] Age ≥ 16 years |
VE % (95% CI) of 4th (2nd booster) dose 13, 14 [Reference: 3 doses] Age ≥ 60 years |
||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Confirmed infection | Delta | Omicron | Delta | Omicron | Omicron |
> 7 days: 93 (78-98)17 ≥ 14 days: 88 (86–89)7 2 weeks: 93 (91-94)16 16 weeks: 78 (68-84)16 |
> 7 days: 54 (23-73)17 < 8 weeks: 75 (50-87)17 > 16 weeks: 55 (5-69)17 |
≥ 7 days: 73 (70–76)9 to 88 (87–90)10 | ≥ 7 days: 11 (7–14)9 to 50 (42-56)17 < 8 weeks: 66 (51-76)17 > 16 weeks: 55 (19-76)17 |
7–30 days: 45 (44–47)1413 14–30 days: 52 (49–54)1514 |
|
Symptomatic infection | Not reported in studies meeting this website’s inclusion criteria- please refer to Methodology | Delta | Omicron | Omicron | |
> 7 days: 80 (62–89)17 to 91 (89–92)10 ≥ 14 days: 84 (78–88)11 |
> 7 days: 39 (23-52)17 to 49 (47–52)12 | 7–30 days: 55 (53–58)13 14–30 days: 61 (58–64)13 |
|||
ED visits | Delta | Omicron | Not reported in studies meeting this website’s inclusion criteria- please refer to Methodology | Not reported in studies meeting this website’s inclusion criteria- please refer to Methodology | |
≥ 14 days: 83 (79–86)1 ≥ 3 months: 72 (58–82)1 |
≥ 14 days: 75 (70–79)1 ≥ 3 months: 53 (36–66)1 |
||||
Severe disease | Delta | Delta | Omicron | ||
2 weeks: 92 (70-98)16 16 weeks: 10016 |
≥ 7 days: 92 (82–97)10 | 7–30 days: 62 (50–74)1413 7–27 days: 73 (66–79)1514 14–30 days: 64 (48–77)1513 |
|||
Hospitalization | Delta | Omicron | Delta | Omicron | Omicron |
≥ 14 days: 87 (81–92)1 to 88 (86–90) 8 2 weeks: 92 (78-97)16 16 weeks: 94 (48- 99)16 ≥ 3 months: 71 (40–86)1 |
≥ 14 days: 82 (77–87)1 ≥ 3 months: 55 (28–71)1 |
≥ 7 days: 79 (71–85)9 to 93 (88–97)10 | > 7 days: 50 (41–57)9 |
7–30 days: 68 (59–74)1413 14–30 days: 72 (63–79)1413 |
|
Death | Delta | Delta | Omicron | ||
2-16 weeks: 10016 1 month: 98 (97-99)15 |
≥ 7 days: 81 (59–97)10 | 7–30 days: 74 (50–90)13 14–30 days: 76 (48–91)13 |
- The initial booster studies were largely conducted during the worldwide Delta and Omicron waves.1, 2, 7-18
- VE has waned over time with new VOC (especially with Omicron as compared to other variants).2, 3, 7, 9, 17
- BNT162b2, in the studies described in this summary, has been associated with reduction of risk against more severe outcomes, such as COVID-19 related hospitalization or death, particularly for individuals who have received booster doses.2, 3, 9-11, 13-16, 18
References: (1) Tartof, Lancet Respir Med, 2022; (2) Patalon; (3) Chemaitelly; (4) CDC COVID-19 Vaccination Schedule for People who are NOT Moderately or Severely Immunocompromised; (5) CDC COVID-19 Vaccination Schedule for People who ARE Moderately or Severely Immunocompromised; (6) Stay Up to Date with COVID-19 Vaccines Including Boosters | CDC.; (7) Tartof, Lancet Reg Health Am, 2022; (8) Drawz; (9) Butt, CID May 2022; (10) Barda; (11) Butt, CID March 2022; (12) Abu-Raddad ; (13) Magen; (14) Gazit; (15) Lytras; (16) Glatman-Freedman EID 2022; (17) Richterman; (18) Sharma