Vaccine Effectiveness of monovalent BNT162b2 Vaccine in Immunocompromised Patients
Page last reviewed 29 November 2022
Key Points
Key Points are meant to be a scientific, factual summary of the available information, focusing on monovalent Pfizer- BioNTech COVID-19 Vaccine or mRNA COVID-19 vaccines, as supported by referenced publications within this section. Conclusions should not be drawn from the inclusion or absence of information.
- Immunocompromised (IC) populations may be susceptible to impaired immune response to vaccination and to severe outcomes, such as hospitalization or death. 1-6 CDC has made updated recommendations for COVID-19 vaccination in individuals 6 months of age and older who are moderately or severely immunocompromised. Please see product labeling and CDC Interim Clinical Considerations for current vaccine dosing regimens and recommendations.7
- Vaccine effectiveness (VE) of monovalent BNT162b2 vaccine has been evaluated in Real-World Evidence (RWE) studies of diverse IC populations, including those with a history of malignancy, organ transplantation, immune-mediated disorders, and immunodeficiencies.1, 4-6
-
RWE Studies in IC patient populations:
- Participants with a history of cancer, rheumatologic disorders, immunodeficiencies, and organ transplantation:
- Three RWE studies conducted in the US described VE of 21-3 and 3 doses2, 3 of monovalent mRNA vaccines against confirmed COVID-19 infection and hospitalization in immunocompromised (those with solid and hematologic malignancies; rheumatologic or inflammatory disorders; organ or stem cell transplant; other intrinsic immune conditions or immunodeficiencies; HIV infection with and without AIDS; previous splenectomy, and use of immunosuppressive medications) and immunocompetent adults, during a Delta (B.1.617.2) predominant period.1
- Vaccine Effectiveness, in % (95% CI), in these populations is summarized below. The listed studies cannot be compared due to differences in study design and methodologies.
- Participants with a history of cancer, rheumatologic disorders, immunodeficiencies, and organ transplantation:
*Confirmed infection= laboratory-confirmed infection with positive SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR.
Study | Embi et al, MMWR 1 | Tenforde et al, MMWR 2 | Tartof et al, Lancet Reg Health Am 3 | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Population | ≥ 18 years, immunocompetent and immunocompromised | ≥ 18 years, immunocompetent and immunocompromised | ≥ 18 years, immunocompetent and immunocompromised | |||||||
Endpoint time period | ≥ 14 days after 2nd dose [Reference: unvaccinated] |
≥28 days after 2nd dose, ≥ 180 days after 2nd dose, ≥7 days after 3rd dose [Reference: unvaccinated] |
≥ 7 days after 2nd dose; ≥ 14 days after 3rd dose [Reference: unvaccinated; ≥ 6 months after 2nddose] |
|||||||
Study period | January 2021- September 2021 (Delta B.1.617.2 variant) |
August 2021- December 2021 (Delta B.1.617.2 variant) |
December 2020- December 2021 (Delta B.1.617.2 variant) |
|||||||
Vaccine effectiveness (VE) outcome: | VE% (95%CI) VE% (95%CI) | VE% (95%CI) VE% (95%CI) | VE% (95%CI) VE% (95%CI) | |||||||
Not reported in this study | Not reported in this study | Vaccine: BNT162b2 |
Immunocompetent (N= 3,042,930) |
Immunocompromised (N=90,145) |
||||||
≥ 7 days after 2nd dose* | 64 (59-68) | 65 (27-83) | ||||||||
≥ 14 days after 3rd dose* | 88 (86-90) | 84 (75-90) | ||||||||
≥ 14 days after 3rd dose# | 76 (72-79) | 68 (49-80) |
Study | Embi et al, MMWR 1 | Tenforde et al, MMWR 2 | Tartof et al, Lancet Reg Health Am 3 | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Population | ≥ 18 years, immunocompetent and immunocompromised | ≥ 18 years, immunocompetent and immunocompromised | ≥ 18 years, immunocompetent and immunocompromised | |||||||
Endpoint time period | ≥ 14 days after 2nd dose [Reference: unvaccinated] |
≥28 days after 2nd dose, ≥ 180 days after 2nd dose, ≥7 days after 3rd dose [Reference: unvaccinated] |
≥ 7 days after 2nd dose; ≥ 14 days after 3rd dose [Reference: unvaccinated; ≥ 6 months after 2nddose] |
|||||||
Study period | January 2021- September 2021 (Delta B.1.617.2 variant) |
August 2021- December 2021 (Delta B.1.617.2 variant) |
December 2020- December 2021 (Delta B.1.617.2 variant) |
|||||||
Vaccine effectiveness (VE) outcome: | VE% (95%CI) VE% (95%CI) | VE% (95%CI) VE% (95%CI) | VE% (95%CI) VE% (95%CI) | |||||||
Vaccine: | Immunocompetent (N= 69,116) |
Immunocompromised (N=20,101) |
Vaccine: Any mRNA Vaccine |
Immunocompetent (N= 1,875) |
Immunocompromised (N=1,077) |
Vaccine: BNT162b2 |
Immunocompetent (N= 3,042,930) |
Immunocompromised (N=90,145) |
||
BNT162b2 (≥ 18 years) |
88 (86-89) | 71 (65-76) | ≥ 28 days after 2nd dose | Not reported | 69 (57-78) | ≥ 7 days after 2nd dose* | 85 (75-91) | 87 (4-98) | ||
Any mRNA Vaccine (≥ 18 years) |
90 (89-91) | 77 (74-80) | ≥ 180 days after 2nd dose | 82 (77-86) | Not reported | ≥ 14 days after 3rd dose* | 98 (96-99) | 87 (70-95) | ||
Any mRNA Vaccine (18-64 years) |
93 (92-94) | 80 (74-84) | ≥ 7 days after 3rd dose | 97 (95-99) | 88 (81-93) | ≥ 14 days after 3rd dose# | 79 (56-90) | 55 (-11-82) | ||
Any mRNA Vaccine (≥ 65 years) |
87 (86-88) | 75 (70-79) |
-
Participants with history of organ transplantation, inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), and immune-mediated inflammatory disease:
- RWE studies have described VE of monovalent BNT162b2 or other mRNA vaccines in solid organ and islet transplant recipients4, in participants with inflammatory bowel disease and exposure to immunosuppressive medications5, and in participants with immune-mediated inflammatory diseases6. Vaccine Effectiveness, in % (95% CI), in these IC populations, compared to unvaccinated participants, is summarized in the table below. The listed studies cannot be compared due to differences in study design and methodologies.
*Confirmed infection= laboratory-confirmed infection with positive SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR.
Study | Callaghan et al, Transplantation4 N= 43,481 |
Khan et al, Gastroenterology5 N= 14,697 |
Widdifield et al, Lancet Rheumatol6 N= 122,518 |
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Population | ≥ 16 years, solid organ and islet transplant recipients | ≥ 18 years, inflammatory bowel disease on immunosuppressive medications | ≥ 16 years, immune-mediated inflammatory disease | |||||
Endpoint time period | >14 days after 2 nd dose | ≥ 7 days after 2 nd dose | ≥ 7 days after 2 nd dose, 3 rd dose | |||||
Study period | September 2020- September 2021 (Delta B.1.617.2 variant) |
December 2020- April 2021 (Variant not reported) |
March 2021- November 2021 (Alpha B.1.1.7, Delta B.1.617.2 variants) |
|||||
Vaccine effectiveness (VE) outcome: | VE% (95% CI) | VE% (the 95% CI was not reported) | VE% (95% CI) | |||||
BNT162b2 | -18 (-48 to 7) | Any mRNA vaccine | 80 | Any mRNA vaccine, 2 nd dose | RA a | 83 (80-86) | ||
Psoriasis | 84 (81-86) | |||||||
IBD b | 79 (74-82) | |||||||
AS c | 89 (83-93) | |||||||
Any mRNA vaccine, 3 rd (booster)dose | RA a | 86 (70-94) | ||||||
Psoriasis | 96 (72-99) | |||||||
IBD b | 76 (47-89) | |||||||
AS c | 82 (20-96) |
Study | Callaghan et al, Transplantation4 N= 43,481 |
Khan et al, Gastroenterology5 N= 14,697 |
Widdifield et al, Lancet Rheumatol6 N= 122,518 |
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Population | ≥ 16 years, solid organ and islet transplant recipients | ≥ 18 years, inflammatory bowel disease on immunosuppressive medications | ≥ 16 years, immune-mediated inflammatory disease | |||||
Endpoint time period | >14 days after 2 nd dose | ≥ 7 days after 2 nd dose | ≥ 7 days after 2 nd dose, 3 rd dose | |||||
Study period | September 2020- September 2021 (Delta B.1.617.2 variant) |
December 2020- April 2021 (Variant not reported) |
March 2021- November 2021 (Alpha B.1.1.7, Delta B.1.617.2 variants) |
|||||
Vaccine effectiveness (VE) outcome: | VE% (95% CI) | VE% (the 95% CI was not reported) | VE% (95% CI) | |||||
Not reported in this study | Any mRNA vaccine | 70 | Ant mRNA vaccine, 2 nd dose | RA a | 92 (88-95) | |||
Psoriasis | 92 (86-95) | |||||||
IBD b | 94 (88-97) | |||||||
AS c | 97 (83-99) | |||||||
Any mRNA vaccine, 3rd (booster)dose | RA a | 88 (48-97) | ||||||
Psoriasis | NR d | |||||||
IBD b | NR d | |||||||
AS c | NR d |
- IC participants were observed to have lower VE against SARS-CoV-2 infection3 and hospitalization1-3, compared to immunocompetent participants, in some of the studies described in this summary.
- Solid organ transplant recipients were observed to have lower VE against confirmed COVID-19 infection4, than the other IC populations5, 6 in the studies described in this summary.
- Two or three doses of monovalent mRNA COVID-19 vaccine provided protection against confirmed COVID-19 infection, and hospitalization or death in participants with immune- mediated inflammatory disease (IBD, RA, AS, psoriasis).5, 6 After two monovalent vaccine doses, effectiveness against infection generally peaked 31–60 days after vaccination and waned gradually with each additional month.6
References: (1) Embi; (2) Tenforde; (3) Tartof; (4) Callaghan;(5) Khan; (6) Widdifield; (7) COVID-19 Vaccines for People Who Are Moderately or Severely Immunocompromised | CDC